Review Index:
Feedback

The Huawei MateBook Review: A Denial-of-Surface Attack

Author:
Subject: Mobile
Manufacturer: Huawei

A new competitor has entered the arena!

When we first saw the announcement of the MateBook in Spain back in March, pricing was immediately impressive. The base model of the tablet starts at just $699; $200 less than the lowest-priced Surface Pro 4, with features and performance that pretty closely match one another.

View Full Size

The MateBook only ships with Core m processors, a necessity of the incredibly thin and fanless design that Huawei is using. That obviously will put the MateBook behind other tablets and notebooks that use the Core i3/i5/i7 processors, but with a power consumption advantage along the way. Honestly, the performance differences between the Core m3 and m5 and m7 parts is pretty small – all share the same 4.5 watt TDP and all have fairly low base clock speeds and high boost clocks. The Core m5-6Y54 that rests in our test sample has a base clock of 1.1 GHz and a maximum Turbo Boost clock of 2.7 GHz. The top end Core m7-6Y75 has a base of 1.2 GHz and Boost of 3.1 GHz. The secret of course is that these processors run at Turbo clocks very infrequently; only during touch interactions and when applications demand performance.

View Full Size

If you work-load regularly requires you to do intensive transcoding, video editing or even high-resolution photo manipulation, the Core m parts are going to be slower than the Core i-series options available in other solutions. If you just occasionally need to use an application like Photoshop, the MateBook has no problems doing so.

Huawei MateBook Tablet PC
MSRP $699 $849 $999 $1199 $1399 $1599
Screen 12-in 2160x1440 IPS
CPU Core m3 Core m3 Core m5 Core m5 Core m7 Core m7
GPU Intel HD Graphics 515
RAM 4GB 8GB
Storage 128GB 256GB 256GB 512GB 256GB 512GB
Network 802.11ac MIMO (2.4 GHz, 5.0 GHz)
Bluetooth 4.1
Gigabite Ethernet (MateDock)
Display Output HDMI / VGA (through MateDock)
Connectivity USB 3.0 Type-C
3.5mm headphone
USB 3.0 x 2 (MateDock)
Audio Dual Digital Mic
Dual Speakers
Weight 640g (1.41 lbs)
Dimensions 278.8mm x 194.1mm x 6.9mm
(10.9-in x 7.6-in x 0.27-in)
Battery 33.7 WHr
Operating System Windows 10 Home / Pro

Update: The Huawei Matebook is now available on Amazon.com!

At the base level, both the Surface Pro 4 and the MateBook have identical specs, but the Huawei unit is priced $200 lower. After that, things get more complicated as the Surface Pro 4 moves to Core i5 and Core i7 processors while the MateBook sticks with m5 and m7 parts. Storage capacities and memory size scale though. The lowest entry point for the MateBook to get 256GB of storage and 8GB of memory is $999 and comes with a Core m5 processor; a comparable Surface Pro 4 uses a Core i5 CPU instead but will run you $1199. If you want to move from 256GB to 512GB of storage, Microsoft wants $400 more for your SP4, while Huawei’s price only goes up $200.

Continue reading our review of the Huawei MateBook convertible PC!!

The MateBook peaks at a Core m7 processor, 8GB of memory, and 512GB of SSD storage, and will run you $1599. If you want to, Microsoft will let you purchase a Surface Pro 4 with 16GB of memory, a 1TB SSD, and a Core i7 processor for $2699.

View Full Size

A performance delta between Intel’s Core m-series and Core i-series definitely exists, but the question you will have to ask is whether you need that in your tablet or notebook replacement. For me, the vast majority of the work I do takes place in a browser or Office document; that includes emails, writing articles, and running basic spreadsheets. In my time with the MateBook I never felt held back, even when running a bit of Photoshop on the side. If I were to purchase one of these outright I would probably spring for the model with 8GB of memory and 256GB of storage for $999, just for a bit more peace of mind and headroom for open applications. Yes, the Surface Pro 4 is going to be faster than the MateBook in benchmarks and performance hungry applications – the question is, how much do you care?

Accessories for both devices are in the same price range and I would argue are essential to making either tablet a solid work machine. We will discuss those more a bit later.

The MateBook Design

The Huawei MateBook looks great. It is an incredibly thin device that feels well built and has the material makeup to make a very strong first impression. It is lighter than and exactly as thin as the 12-in iPad Pro which is an impressive feat from the first time PC builder.

View Full Size

The only connection (save the 3.5mm audio jack) on the MateBook is a USB 3.0 Type-C port that provides data and accessory connectivity as well as power input. The tablet will ship with a power adapter and one Type-C to micro-USB converter, and an optional dock is available to offer expansion for standard USB, display output, and hardwired network connectivity. Not having a standard USB port on the machine is definitely a drawback, and will require a bit of planning on your part.

View Full Size

The top button on the tablet is your wake and power button. Around the corner you will find the hardware volume rocker with a very capable and impressively thin fingerprint reader. I set up Windows Hello (a stupid name) with it and it works great – very fast and very accurate despite the small size.

View Full Size

At the top of the bezel is a basic webcam for conferencing and Skype calls. It works as expected.

The speakers are located along the top of the MateBook and they sound as good as you could expect for a tablet this thin. Without space for a lot of air movement, they sound hollow. They do get quite loud though, so if you are listening to spoken content and need pure volume, the MateBook has you covered. I would put the sound quality on par with other ultra-thin notebooks.

View Full Size

Along the left corner we find a standard 3.5mm headphone jack and a single microphone for audio conferencing.

Finally, on the bottom of the MateBook is a connection used to mount the tablet to the keyboard dock and portfolio. Not using Bluetooth for the keyboard and touchpad should mean less battery consumption when working on the device and it also allows the keyboard to get power to illuminate the keys without needing a battery.


June 28, 2016 | 12:35 PM - Posted by Gina (not verified)

Has anyone ever monitored the IP traffic this device sends out? As a Chinese company sanctioned by the US NSA and supported by a regime which has the largest state sponsored hacking in the world, I'd be worried about how much of my personal data is being sent back to mainland China.

June 28, 2016 | 02:00 PM - Posted by Anonymous (not verified)

If you're an American citizen living in the U.S., and you're concerned with "state-sponsored" hacking or monitoring, I would think you'd be more concerned with the NSA since the Chinese government probably doesn't give a crap about you, and has no power over you even if they do. If you're worried about your "personal date being sent back to mainland China" for criminal purposes (identity theft, credit card fraud, etc..), that would at least make more sense, although that would imply that Huawei is completely out of their collective minds (and won't be doing business in the U.S. market much longer), or are unknowingly compromised. There's no reason to think that's the case any more than all the other companies that have their products manufactured in China (almost everyone), and/or companies that come from China and have their main headquarters there.

Tell me, what makes Huawei any different than, say, Lenovo for example? Both are Chinese companies, and both have their headquarters in mainland China (in Lenovo's case, Beijing). All the electronic devices you own have probably been manufactured there. Nothing is safe, by your logic, and honestly, it's not crazy to think that way about all the electronic stuff we have in our lives. It's silly though to focus on this particular device or company as though it's a special case.

June 28, 2016 | 05:43 PM - Posted by Anonymous (not verified)

Do you not remember to mere months ago with Lenovo's Superfish scandal? Your comparison is terrible.

November 11, 2016 | 10:44 AM - Posted by Da (not verified)

Huawei is also the worlds largest telecommunications equipment company and was banned as such in the US because it would significantly compromise the market share of Cisco, an American company. Their electronic devices, however, are fine.

June 28, 2016 | 12:43 PM - Posted by Bianchi4me (not verified)

Generally, people that are worried about saving $200 aren't shopping for Surface Pro anyway. Not enough of a price separation for premium buyers to roll the dice on an unknown product from a brand they've likely never heard of... unless street pricing winds up well below MSRP.

June 29, 2016 | 03:59 AM - Posted by Jann5s

You have to understand how big huawei is, maybe in your country it's not well know, but worldwide huawei is well known and very respected.

June 29, 2016 | 08:47 PM - Posted by Bianchi4Me (not verified)

Well known as a maker of value-oriented cellphones and accessories. Their previous presence in the PC industry is zero. I have been happy with ZTE and BLU smartphones, but I wouldn't buy their very first-ever PC model to save $200 on a $1000 item. Admittedly, there are places in the world where $200 saved is a much bigger concern, but is there a huge market for ultra-premium laptops in those places?

July 20, 2016 | 09:57 AM - Posted by Anonymous (not verified)

No offense - but you really don't seem to know what you're talking about. Huawei has made great flagship phones and the Huawei P9 competes and beats just about every flagship available besides the HTC 10 and Samsung S7 - in which case it at the least ties. Although they didn't have a presence, they are trusted enough to the point that I can see myself buying the Matebook over the Surface pro. Your argument is like saying that no one should've bought the first iPhone because Apple had no presence in the phone market - would've been a terrible choice.

June 29, 2016 | 09:41 AM - Posted by Gunbuster

Not having an integrated stand kills it for me. I cant stand those fold up folio cases...

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <blockquote><p><br>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.