Review Index:
Feedback

Thrustmaster TX F458 Ferrari Italia Edition Review: Stepping Up the Wheel Game

Author:
Subject: General Tech
Manufacturer: Thrustmaster

Taking Racing Games a Step Further

I remember very distinctly the first racing game I had ever played and where.  It was in the basement of a hotel in Billings, MT where I first put a couple of quarters through the ATARI Night Driver arcade machine.  It was a very basic simulator with white dots coming at you as if they were reflectors on poles.  The game had a wheel and four gears available through a shifter.  It had an accelerator and no brake.  It was the simplest racing game a person could play.  I was pretty young, so it was not as fun to me because I did not do well actually playing it.  Like most kids that age, fun is in the anticipation of playing and putting the quarter in rather than learning the intricacies of a game.

View Full Size

Throughout the years there were distinct improvements.  I played Pole Position and Enduro on the ATARI 2600, I had my first PC racer with Test Drive (the Ferrari Testarossa was my favorite vehicle) using only the keyboard.  I took a break for a few years and did not get back into racing games until I attended the 3dfx T-buffer demo when I saw the latest NFS 4 (High Stakes) played at 1024x768 with AA enabled.  Sure, it looked like the cars were covered in baby oil, but that was not a bad thing at the time.

One of the real breakthrough titles for me was NFS: Porsche Unleashed.  EA worked with Porsche to create a game that was much closer to a simulation than the previous arcade racers.  It was not perfect, but it was one of the first titles to support Force Feedback in racing.  I purchased a Microsoft Sidewinder Force Feedback 2 joystick.  The addition of FFB was a tremendous improvement in the game as I could feel the tires start to slip and experience the increased resistance to turns.  This was my first real attempt at a racing game and actually completing it.  I still have fond memories and it would be great to get a remastered version with better graphics and physics, while still retaining the simulation roots.

After PU I again stopped playing racers.  The release of Project Gotham racing for the XBox rekindled that a bit, but I soon tired of the feel of the controller and the rumble rather than real FFB effects.  Fast forward to Quakecon 2009 when I saw the first gameplay videos of the upcoming DiRT 2.  This title was one of the first to adopt DX11 that would push the HD 5800 and GTX 480 video cards for all they were worth.  This re-ignited my desire to race.  I purchased DiRT 2 as soon as it was available for the PC and played with the aging (but still solid) Sidewinder FFB P2.

View Full Size

The box was a little beat up when it got to me, but everything was intact.

Something was missing though.  I really wanted more out of my racing game.  The last time I had used a wheel on a racing game was probably an Outrun arcade machine in the late 80s.  I did some shopping around and decided on the Thrustmaster F430 Ferrari FFB wheel.  It was on sale at the time for a low, low price of $76.  It had a 270 degree rotation which is more apt for arcade racers than sims, but it was a solid wheel for not a whole lot of money.  It was a fantastic buy for the time and helped turn me into a racing enthusiast.

During this time I purchased my kids a couple of low end wheels that use the bungee cord centering mechanism.  These of course lack any FFB features, but the Genius one I acquired was supposed to have some basic feedback and rumble effects: it never worked as such.  So, my experience to this point has been joysticks, bungee wheels, and a 270 degree F430 wheel.  This does not make me an expert, but it does provide an interesting background for the jump to a higher level of product.

Click here to continue reading the Thrustmaster TX F458 Italia Edition Review!

The TX F458 Ferrari Italia Edition

This particular wheel is the lowest priced option of their upper end TX series of wheels and bases.  The older F430 I had used before had a non-detachable wheel and the base was powered by a single motor attached to a mixed belt and helical gear system.  The TX series uses a full dual belt and pulley system with what they term as “an industrial-class brushless motor”.

View Full Size

The very first thing we see is the warning to read the directions first and update the firmware on the wheel!

The base unit is used across a couple of products in the Thrustmaster lineup, but this one is meant for the PC and XBox One.  This is a slightly older and less expensive base than what is found on higher end parts with a corresponding higher price.  The base has up to 900 degrees of rotation as compared to other bases that have up to 1080 degrees.  This is obviously a massive improvement over the 270 degrees of the F430.

The wheel itself is a replica of that found in the Ferrari F458, but 7/10 the size of the real.  The wheel itself is detachable with the (somewhat) quick release attachment found on Thrustmaster products.  This quick release is a screw-on sleeve that is locked by a smaller screw once it is tightly attached.  This takes a minute or so to put on or take off, so do not expect a fast release like what we see on professional race cars.  The wheel features 10 buttons plus a D-pad disguised as the starter button.  The paddle shifters are large metal units attached to the back of the wheel and not the base unit.

View Full Size

It does not have a huge amount of packaging, but it again arrived undamaged and intact.

The TX F458 comes with a two pedal unit rather than the 3 pedal unit the higher end models show up with.  Considering that the setup does not include the 8 speed shifter, a clutch is not necessarily needed.  If a user does in fact purchase the 8 speed shifter they can upgrade the pedals to the lower end T3PA unit, or the top end T3PA-Pro.  The acceleration pedal has a long travel throw while the brake features progressive resistance.

Video News


September 24, 2015 | 01:21 AM - Posted by Humanitarian

I've been thinking about upgrading to a belt driven wheel for awhile, or even a belt-gear hybrid. my g27 can get ridiculously rattly in certain scenarios (flat out in the 125cc superkart on project cars makes it sound like a jackhammer)

September 24, 2015 | 09:55 AM - Posted by Josh Walrath

I'm really curious how the newer Logi wheels are as compared to the G27 and a product like this TX.  The motors/gears on the new Logis do look like an upgrade from the G27, but a big enough one?  I don't know!  Maybe I'll get a chance to play with the G920, but I'm not holding my breath.

September 24, 2015 | 01:47 AM - Posted by Master Chen (not verified)

Thrustmaster are GODS.

November 4, 2015 | 09:44 PM - Posted by mLocke

T300 RS is on sale as of writing this for $349.99

Thurstmaster MSRP list
--- | $129.99 | 28 cm | Ferrari GTE Wheel Add-On Ferrari 458 Challenge Edition
--- | $149.99 | 28 cm | TM Leather 28 GT Wheel
--- | $179.99 | 30 cm | 599XX EVO 30 Wheel Add-On Alcantara Edition
PS4 | $199.99 | 28 cm | T150 (12-bit sensor)
XBO | $259.99 | ----- | TX Servo Base
XBO | $299.99 | 28 cm | TX Racing Wheel Ferrari 458 Italia Edition
PS4 | $399.99 | 28 cm | T300 RS
XBO | $469.99 | 28 cm | TX Racing Wheel Leather Edition
PS4 | $469.99 | 30 cm | T300 Ferrari Integral Racing Wheel Alcantara Edition

September 24, 2015 | 07:20 AM - Posted by Branthog

I miss the days when Thrustmaster were a respectable awesome company out of Beaverton Oregon. Back before they were bought out and just started making cheap chinese crap.

September 24, 2015 | 09:59 AM - Posted by Josh Walrath

Didn't realize they were originally out of Beverton.  That's kinda cool.

As for quality, I'm not sure what to say about that.  I have been using the old F430 pretty much constantly since 2011 and it has held up like a champ.  The only problem I ever had with that one was that my father-in-law really jammed the wheel over hard and I think wore down one of the cogs.  Still works fine, but one section of the turning radius of that wheel got a little chunky.

So far I have been using the TX for about two months now and it has been flawless.  Feels great, doesn't overheat, and worked without issue once firmware was updated and latest drivers installed.

September 24, 2015 | 07:57 PM - Posted by Anonymous (not verified)

Josh. Get a hold of the Accuforce. I hear that wheel is suppose to change your life and make you crap kittens or something. Apparently direct drive is going to be the way to go if you can afford it.

September 25, 2015 | 08:55 AM - Posted by Josh Walrath

Holy crap, for $1800 it better be sweet!

September 24, 2015 | 09:04 AM - Posted by obababoy

I've been looking into a wheel for the past couple weeks now, but I just can't get myself to go in on the TX wheel. The only benefit to this one over the logitech G920 is the belt driven force feedback...well and price. I have read about many durability issues with the lower end TX wheels and the lack of 3 pedals is frustrating(so is the fact that the G920 doesnt come with a shifter). I play on XB1 and PC so Project Cars, Dirt Rally and Forza 6 will be my go to games. I currently only have Forza 5 and Project Cars(PC).

I'll probably end up going G920 but that will do a disservice to gamers because the G27 SHOULD work on newer consoles and the G920 is a re-badged albeit better pedaled wheel compared to the G27.

September 24, 2015 | 11:10 AM - Posted by Josh Walrath

Yeah, it is a bummer that the older wheels aren't supported on the new consoles.

My only long term experience with Thrustmaster quality is that F430 wheel I wrote about in this review.  I have had that since 2011 and used it quite a bit over the years.  The gearing on that got a little rough in one area due to it getting slightly stripped due to some excessive force.  Otherwise, it worked flawlessly over those years.

September 25, 2015 | 05:10 AM - Posted by mum1989 (not verified)

Don't forget Assetto Corsa to test wheel

September 25, 2015 | 08:55 AM - Posted by Josh Walrath

Still haven't purchased that one yet.

October 7, 2015 | 08:21 AM - Posted by Anonymous (not verified)

You need to look on Amazon and around the net in general to see other user impressions.

http://www.amazon.co.uk/product-reviews/B00EVR2FIS/ref=cm_cr_dp_hist_one...

These steering wheels are really badly made and have terrible reliability issues.

Try contacting Thrustmaster support for help - you'll often wait at least 2 weeks for a reply.

I ended retuning mine to Amazon after the wheel failed to work correctly (I really wish I'd kept my Fanatec Forza Elite - it was so much better, but I didn't realise at the time).

Thrustmaster did reply eventually (3 weeks later) but I told them in no uncertain terms that I'd never use another Thrustmaster product again due to their terrible customer support.

This really should be taken into account when buying any Thrustmaster product.

October 8, 2015 | 01:34 PM - Posted by Josh Walrath

Thanks for your input here.  I have heard mixed reviews of Thrustmaster support.  Some have had good experiences, some have had bad.  Will be curious if my wheel ever develops any issues.  My previous TM wheel lasted great for 5 years or so.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <blockquote><p><br>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.