Delidding your Intel Haswell CPU
Putting it all back together
Once the processor has been delidded, you have two options for running the processor in your system:
- Use the CPU with naked die, requiring use of some type of spacer to protect the die from being crushed
- Replace the heat spreader on the CPU after careful reapplication of your choice of thermal paste
Naked Die Approach
Going with the naked die approach may net you the best temperatures, but it is also the most perilous and could easily result in a cracked die or dead CPU. You will need to obtain a CPU spacer specially made for your Haswell CPU to protect the naked die against uneven forced exerted upon it when fixing the CPU cooler in place.
MSI includes such a device, dubbed the MSI Die Guard, in with their Z97 XPower motherboard. To use MSI's spacer, you must first take apart the existing socket hardware using a T20 torx headed screwdriver, carefully place the CPU in the socket, and then fix the MSI Die Guard in place using the socket screws and the socket backplate.
If you have reassembled the socket corrected with the CPU in place, it should reassemble the socket picture shown above. At that point, you carefully mount the CPU cooler in place and fire up your system. If all went well, you should notice significant temperature improvements.
Heat Spreader Approach
If you choose to re-use the heat spreader, you simply coat the CPU die with a very thin layer of your choice of thermal paste and gently place the heat spreader back on top of the CPU PCB. Make sure that the orientation of the heat spread is correct or you risk severly damaging the chip. Then place the CPU back into the socket and lock it in place with the socket hardware. If you so desire, you can remove the CPU from the board and remove the heat spreader, to check that the heat spreader and die are making good contact. At that point, simply put it all back together with the CPU cooler and power on the system. While the temperatures you see with this method will not be as low as with direct die cooling, you have much less of a risk of cracking or crushing the CPU die.
Being that I have had much experience with naked die cooling from back in the days when AMD still shipped their CPUs without heat spreaders, I was certain that I was up to the task to handle direct die cooling of my Intel 4770K CPU in conjuction with the MSI Die Guard. It did work for a little while. I saw major decreases in running temps, upwards of 10-20C with much better temperature consistency across the cores. Being the tinker I am, I decided to see if I could get better temperatures with different water blocks - thats where the problems began. On my next system boot, one or two of my cores jumped to 100C under load even with the CPU at stock clock settings.
I removed the CPU only to find that the CPU die has spider-webbed on me as shown above, even with the MSI Die Guard securely and correctly in place. Luckily, the CPU was not totally dead but was unusable in its current state for prolonged period of time (read that as usable in my primary system). Your mileage may vary on this, but if you do decide to delid your processor, I would recommend going with the heat spreader approach and not even attempt the direct die cooling. It could be a costly adventure if you do...