Duron vs. Thunderbird
Cooling Considerations
This content was originally featured on Amdmb.com and has been converted to PC Perspective's website. Some color changes and flaws may appear.

Cooling these processors was a major consideration before any of the testing was completed. Even at their default speed, the Duron and Thunderbird create an intense amount of heat and using an improper heatsink/fan combination will surely leave you with a dead hunk of silicon on your hands.
The Thunderbird 800 MHz was my second of this processor, the first of which is laying the stack of computer hardware labeled “I’m a dumbass.” While using my first Socket A motherboard, the AZ11 from FIC, I had a heatsink that was large and seemed competent for the job at hand: cooling a Socket A 800 MHz processor. I used it on Coppermines before, and the sockets and nearly identical in size, so I gave it a go. After about 15 seconds on the test bench, during initial posting and boot up, I noticed the air had a scent of “burn” in it. I quickly unplugged the power supply, and removed the heatsink from the motherboard. Taking the processor out showed to be more difficult, as nearly touching it singed my fingers. I ended up getting it out using a ball-point pen (also not a good idea) and was shocked to see the warranty sticker MCS had placed on the bottom of the CPU, once bright green color was now a charred-brown color.

So, I then called my sales rep at MCS and had them send me five of their heatsinks that were AMD approved, and I have never had problem since. Many of you may wonder whether or not the overclocking of the CPUs demands a better, larger fan or heatsink. While I haven’t done any intense testing on the subject, my opinion is this: if you are overclocking to over 1 GHz, you need better cooling. If you are staying under the 1000 level, and AMD approved heatsink will work well enough.
The heatsink/fan combination we used was the CoolerMaster DP5-5H-51. We also used some copper heat plates from 3DCOOL.COM that simply give the CPU more area with which to move heat to the heatsink with.
As mentioned earlier, testing a 700 MHz processor against an 800 MHz processor really isn’t fair in any aspect. So, I decided to overclock the CPUs to reach an equal speed. But instead of just bringing the 700 MHz Duron up to the 800 Mhz of the Thunderbird, I decided to go one step further and push both processors to 900 MHz. This way, the testing is showing the results of the higher end, newer processors instead of “out-dated” 800 MHz ones. :)

Post new comment