Review Index:
Feedback

The Microsoft Surface Book and Surface Pro 4 Review

Author:
Subject: Mobile
Manufacturer: Microsoft

Design - A Tablet and a Notebook

For the last 30 days or so, I have been using both Microsoft's new Surface Book and Surface Pro 4 as every day computing devices. The goal was to review these items from not just a handful of days of testing and benchmarking, but with some lengthy time under my belt utilizing both products in a real-world environment. The following is my review with that premise. Enjoy!


A lot has already been said about the design and style of both the updated Surface Pro 4 and the new Surface Book. Let’s start with the Surface Pro 4 as it sees the least dramatic changes from previous product.

The Surface Pro 4 uses the same kickstand tablet design that made the Surface brand so memorable as well as functional.  Many different OEMs are starting to copy the design style because it has a lot of positive merits to it. For instance, it allows viewing angles from nearly 90 degree to flat. The Surface Pro 4 is a tablet in its purest form, though. It doesn’t have a keyboard or trackpad standard – you’ll have purchase the optional Type Cover. It’s only 8.5mm thick and weighs in at 1.73 lbs, without the added keyboard.

View Full Size

The kickstand works exceptionally, with unlimited positions between the starting and stop point of the hinge, and it allows smooth movement between them. It’s strong enough to stand up when being slid around on the tablet or desk. The biggest concern I have with the kickstand is that using it on your lap (or on an airplane tray table) is difficult to impossible, depending on the exact configuration or your legs / tray. Because the hinged kickstand needs a surface to make contact with, pushing the Surface Pro back on your legs where the hinged portion extends past your knees won’t work.

View Full Size

From a design and style perspective, I still think the Surface products are among the best that exist on the market today. The magnesium body is sleek and the angles are both professional and aggressive. Even when coupled with the magnetic Type Cover, it won’t look like a toy at the office or on the road.

The new Surface Book is a completely different beast – a unique design and a new product. I am sure that there are some people that simply won’t like the way the notebook looks, but I am not one of them. Though it is technically a tablet and a keyboard dock, the Surface Book only ships as a complete unit so calling this a notebook or a 2-in-1 convertible feels more accurate than calling it a tablet. It has a larger and more pronounced 13.5-in screen than the Pro, which makes it larger, heavier and bulkier in your bag as well. The magnesium body shares a lot of design cues with the Pro 4, but it’s the hinge on the Book that really makes it different than any notebook I have used.

Continue reading our review of the Microsoft Surface Book and Surface Pro 4!!

View Full Size

The hinge has a watch band styling to it. This helps to keep the unit extended out further from the keyboard dock while maintaining balance as far back as possible with the screen extended. The latch to disconnect the screen from the keyboard is electronic, using a technology Microsoft calls Muscle Wire. Detaching is initiated with a long press of a button on the keyboard and the software is then given time to disconnect the discrete GPU (if your keyboard dock has it) in software before allowing you to remove the tablet portion. If you pull it out too early (which I did a couple of times) be prepared for an immediate blue screen.

View Full Size

I’ll talk more about the keyboard and trackpad below, but I do want to point out my one concern with the Surface Book, which is the maximum angle that you can bend the screen back. It is limited compared to standard notebooks (and definitely the Surface Pro 4) because most of the components and hardware are in the tablet half of the Book. Bending it any further back would cause the whole device to tip over. Most of the people that I have showed the Surface Book to believe that the range Microsoft provided with this first iteration is enough for them to use the notebook comfortably, and I agree – I just worry there will be circumstances that arise that will cause issue. It’s a systemic problem with 2-in-1 notebooks, and not limited to Microsoft, but it’s something to be aware of regardless.

Though I’m not 100% sold on it, I think the unique hinge and design on the Surface Book is a positive trait – it stands out in a crowd and is completely functional with all of the features and capabilities of the Surface Pro and a normal notebook. You are going to pay a penalty in weight and size for the Surface Book though – it is as much as 22.8mm thick (more than 2x the Surface Pro 4) and 3.34 lbs. (nearly 2x the Surface Pro 4 before adding the Type Cover).

Screen – 3:2 Ratio High DPI

View Full Size

The initial thought that went through my head when I first started to use the new Surface devices was the “odd” aspect ratio that both utilize. With a 3:2 ratio, more similar to that of an iPad than other notebooks on the market, the screens just feel taller than you expect. Previous Surface devices used this aspect ratio so it won’t surprise anyone that might be upgrade from older hardware; users coming from a standard notebook (like my Dell XPS 13) that uses a 16:9 screen you will definitely have to adjust. That being said, the 3:2 aspect ratio turned out to be perfect for my more business-based usage with both the Surface Pro 4 and Surface Book. You can get more of a vertical word document, more of a webpage or more of a text document on the screen at home time when maximized. Working on 16:9 content like PowerPoint slides or video will leave you with wasted space along the top and bottom of the screen though, so it’s a tradeoff.

View Full Size

Resolution on both screens is very high, with the Surface Book sporting a 3000x2000 13.5-in panel and the Surface Pro 4 2736x1824 12.3-in panel. The Surface Book will feel big with that 13.5 diagonal measurement to many buyers – it’s taller than other 13- or 14-in displays used on notebooks today. The PPI (pixels per inch) on both is very high, above 260 ppi, meaning you’ll have incredibly sharp text and images where it’s supported. Windows 10 does a great job with scaling compared to even Windows 8.1 and I had very little issue dealing with scaling issues. There are exceptions, older programs that haven’t been updated in a long time, but they are becoming less common as more devices default to 150%+ scaling out of the box.

View Full Size

Both the Book and Pro 4 have glossy screens and support 10-point touch interface, along with the Surface Pen I’ll discuss below. They are top quality LCD panels from our testing and use though the glossiness of the glass will result in some unwanted reflections from time to time. 


December 21, 2015 | 12:57 PM - Posted by Jay S (not verified)

Is it possible to take video with the rear camera in "laptop mode" not "tablet mode"?

I want to continue to take notes in laptop mode, but also take video of my lectures with the rear view camera.

December 21, 2015 | 01:00 PM - Posted by Ryan Shrout

Hmm, I can try to find out. What application would you record video with?

December 21, 2015 | 02:24 PM - Posted by Michael Ciancio (not verified)

My Surface Pro 3 can do that. You use the Camera app that comes installed on it and it works fine.

December 21, 2015 | 03:34 PM - Posted by CB (not verified)

Ryan, I think your argument about the discrete GPU not being worth it unless one plans on gaming or doing GPU intensive tasks is spot on.

I've seen a couple other sights see about 12% battery life improvements in models without the discrete GPU. Doesn't sound like much, but that's over an hour extra for $200 less...

December 21, 2015 | 08:41 PM - Posted by pdjblum

Very instructive and helpful. Thanks. Many of the non-tech people I know who have always used windows laptops are looking at Apple laptops now. Assuming it isn't about the op system, but rather about the way it looks and feels, would you say this on par? Fortunately I have never had to own a laptop and the ones I have used were windows machines, so I am in no position to guide them.

December 22, 2015 | 01:24 AM - Posted by Tom N. (not verified)

Thanks Ryan, is it possible that the power connector blocks the displayport connector so you cannot use both at the same time?

December 23, 2015 | 04:34 PM - Posted by Ryan Shrout

The power connector is rotatable so you can avoid that.

December 22, 2015 | 01:25 AM - Posted by Tom N. (not verified)

On the surface book...

December 22, 2015 | 08:35 AM - Posted by Boo (not verified)

Hi Ryan,
some corrections for your summary table.

The Surface Pro 4 i7 is not the Core i7-6500U but it's the Core i7-6650U that has better GPU than 6500U.

The 6650U has the Intel HD-540 (Iris Graphics) instead of HD-520.

While the Surface Book i7 version is the 6600U that has HD-520 (but it is not 6500U)

So the SP4 i7 is much better than the SB i7 (without nVidia).

Here some source:
http://www.pcworld.com/article/2989906/laptop-computers/here-are-the-det...

http://ark.intel.com/it/products/family/88392/6th-Generation-Intel-Core-...

December 23, 2015 | 04:41 PM - Posted by Ryan Shrout

Interesting, thanks.

Updated!

December 22, 2015 | 02:48 PM - Posted by Anirudh (not verified)

Hi Ryan,

Have you tried editing GoPro videos on Surface Book?

Thanks,

December 23, 2015 | 04:36 PM - Posted by Ryan Shrout

Can't say that I have. Sorry!

December 22, 2015 | 05:13 PM - Posted by Anonymous (not verified)

I use the Surface Book for live-stream video productions and editing in real-time for my church. I also use it heavily with Photoshop/Illustrator. I do high-res graphics that are the size of billboard banners. I have not had this machine slow down on me for a single beat.

i7 with Nvidia

December 23, 2015 | 09:31 AM - Posted by hannah (not verified)

Does anybody know:

Is it possible ANYWHERE to get the surface book with 512gb *without* nvidia GPU?

I want the storage but have no desire for the nvidia.

Do you think this will be an option in the future? Should I wait?

Thanks!

December 23, 2015 | 07:41 PM - Posted by Anonymous (not verified)

The price is too high.

January 1, 2016 | 08:58 PM - Posted by John Shaw (not verified)

Just wondering... Has anyone else noticed that the Surface Book fulcrum is identical to the hinge on the Martian heat ray weapon in the "War of the Worlds" (1953) movie?

January 13, 2016 | 05:42 AM - Posted by MiraBleko (not verified)

You can’t help but love the specs. http://www.interwebcom.com/microsoft-surface-book-review/

But I found the Surface Book a bit awkward while converting it from laptop to desktop mode.
The older Surface tablets connect to the Type Cover keyboard via fabric hinge. It works pretty well, but there’s always a tiny bit of flex. Worse still is the kickstand, which Microsoft has never quite figured out how to prevent it from digging into your thighs. The hinge solves all that, holding the monstrous tablet securely. It doesn’t wiggle. Internal, toothlike hooks help secure the tablet to the base.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <blockquote><p><br>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.