Sitting in the storage sweet spot
Subject: Storage | March 25, 2008 - 06:46 PM | Jeremy Hellstrom
Western Digital's Caviar SE16 640GB sits at a nice place in the storage market. Weighing in at ~$150 on Pricegrabber, a pair of 320GB platters and a 16MB cache size this drive has great price for it's size and performance. In the full review over at The Tech Report, they discovered two other things to love; the power consumption is about that of the low powered Green Power HDD series and it is one of the quietest drives they have found.
"When Western Digital introduced its GreenPower line with the terabyte Caviar GP last year, we wished aloud that the
drive's new 250GB platters would make their way into a performance-oriented model. The GP wasn't even particularly
slow—in fact, it was the fastest terabyte drive at the time. But by dialing back the GreenPower's spindle speed to close
to 5,400RPM in a bid to improve energy efficiency, WD effectively left some performance on the table. We've been waiting
to get that performance back ever since.
Unfortunately, it seems Western Digital had no plans to sate our desire for a terabyte Caviar with 250GB platters
spinning at a full 7,200RPM. Instead, the company has almost done one better by launching a new batch of 7,200-RPM
Caviars that pack an impressive 320GB per platter. These new drives are only available in capacities up to 640GB, so
they won't challenge for the terabyte crown. With prices hovering around $130 for the 640GB model, however, this latest
crop of Caviar nails the cost-per-gigabyte sweet spot that most enthusiasts covet.
The question, of course, is how this new Caviar SE16 640GB measures up. Can Western Digital's new Caviar models match up
with Samsung's best-in-class SpinPoint F1? And with only two platters, does this new SE16's noise levels and power
consumption compete with energy-efficient drives like the Caviar GP? Keep reading to find out."
Here are some more Storage reviews from around the web:
- Western Digital 640GB - Twice the
Platters, Twice the Fun @ AnandTech
- Thermaltake BlacX HDD Docking
Station @ techPowerUp
- Thecus N299 NAS Server
Review @ Virtual-Hideout
- WD Caviar and RE2 GreenPower 1TB Hard Drives @ HotHardware
- Mediasonic SU2LA Dual Bay RAID + NAS Enclosure Review @ Hardware Canucks
- Icy Box NAS 4220 Enclosure Review @
Luxon Advanced ED HDD Enclosure 1TB eSATA=Sweet @ BCCHardware
- Raidsonic Icy Box IB-3218StU-B
Review @ Rbmods
- Thermaltake BlacX Hard Drive Docking System Review
- Paragon Disk Manager 2008 Suite @
- 27 Card Readers
Roundup @ X-Bit Labs
- OCZ Rally 2 USB Drive @
Get notified when we go live!